The Wandering Hangman - Challenge 1

For : Challenge: The Wandering Hangman"A
hoy Cutlads and Cutlasses! I've heard rumours that a strange ship roams this waters, going by the name of "The Wandering Hangman". The ship is either a ghost ship or cursed, but everyone I talked to seems to be extremely frightened. They only whispered the name and looked around to see if anybody heard them. So far, I was unable to find out much about the Captain, but he is associated with instant death or at least horrible misery. Regardless what truth lays behind the rumours, we should be careful as long as we're here. I don't intend to be a corpse anytime soon.."
Captain Maggie
Challenge Goal
Encounter "The Wandering Hangman" and make the result spooky. What exactly happens is up to you. You can do either of the following tasks, or both, but you can only submit one entry per challenge.
I. Palette Challenge
Draw a picture using only the following colours: black, orange, blue, brown, yellow.
You have to include a background

Maggie is being followed by a dark shadow  

Rushed this within 3-4 hours after finally deciding on the colours (see left): dark blue, black, brown, orange, light yellow, all there
Also, no opacity tricks, just using thick and thin lines. Must... resist... urge to... blend...

EDIT: Forgot her scar, added it now